Standard tests underestimate nonverbal children with autism
R. Kremen Missed opportunities: Hanna Suzuki’s intellectual abilities were overlooked because of her verbal deficits.
Nonverbal doesn’t mean incapable. A pilot study of children with autism who have low or no verbal skills suggests that the right intelligence tests can reveal their hidden potential.
The findings, published 6 March in Molecular Autism, add to mounting evidence that standard intelligence tests underestimate the abilities of some children with autism. Alternative tests that tap their strengths, which may include pattern recognition and visual acuity, are likely to paint a more accurate picture of their cognitive abilities.
“This study shows even children with autism who we think appear as low-functioning might have intellectual potential that we are either not aware of, or underestimate,” says lead researcher Isabelle Soulières, assistant professor of psychology at the University of Quebec in Montreal.
Soulières and her team studied 30 children with autism who had little or no verbal ability. None of the children could complete the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children — a widely used intelligence test that relies heavily on verbal communication. But when the scientists used a picture-based test called the Raven’s Colored Progressive Matrices, 65 percent of the children scored in the normal range. Ten percent ranked in the 90th percentile.
In this test, participants complete a set of puzzle-like matrices by inserting the correct piece into the blank spot. No verbal instructions are given; the tester simply points to the blank space.
The researchers also administered the Children’s Embedded Figure Test, which involves finding hidden pictures, and visual search tests, in which the child locates a particular symbol amongst many similar symbols. Results for all three tests correlated. The consistency of these scores suggests that picture-based tests can reliably reveal intellectual ability in these children — one rooted in spatial rather than verbal skills.
“I think that developing alternative assessments for children with autism could uncover hidden potential and result in adaptations to how they are taught at school,” says Soulières.
I can easily believe that traditional tests underestimate some children with severe autism. One low-verbal girl I’ve met, 12-year-old Hanna Suzuki, was underestimated due to her limited verbal and motor skills. For years, teachers assumed that she had a significant intellectual delay. When she was 10, she was assigned first-grade math problems even though, it later surfaced, the math was far too easy for her. Using her body effectively and verbalizing the answers had been the obstacle.
Finally, last year Hanna tried a therapy called the Rapid Prompting Method. This approach, which teaches people to communicate by typing, often reveals that students have already taught themselves to read and spell. In a low-distraction environment, children gradually learn to focus, and to coordinate their bodies enough to point. They then learn to insert a stick through letters in a stencil and, sometimes, even to type.
Slowly and laboriously, Hanna can now peck out sentences on an iPad or keyboard. Though she struggles to hit the right keys and stay on task, her writing reflects thoughtful, age-appropriate language. When I asked about her past school experiences, she typed: “The work was not at my level,” referring to the lack of challenge. “I felt incapable.”
Hanna is now studying algebra and enjoys grade-level science lessons. She even interviews people in the community about their jobs, as a part of her therapy. “[My life] has changed tremendously,” she wrote. “I am so hopeful.”
Editor’s note: This article reflects the writer’s opinion. SFARI.org does not endorse the Rapid Prompting Method or any of the opinions described here.
**mind vault**
mind vault is a premium cognitive support formula created for adults 45+. It’s thoughtfully designed to help maintain clear thinking
**neuro sharp**
neurosharp is a high-quality cognitive support formula made to elevate memory, attention, and overall mental performance.
**prostadine**
prostadine is a next-generation prostate support formula designed to help maintain, restore, and enhance optimal male prostate performance.
**sugarmute**
sugarmute is a science-guided nutritional supplement created to help maintain balanced blood sugar while supporting steady energy and mental clarity.
**glpro**
glpro is a natural dietary supplement designed to promote balanced blood sugar levels and curb sugar cravings.
**mitolyn**
mitolyn a nature-inspired supplement crafted to elevate metabolic activity and support sustainable weight management.
**zencortex**
zencortex contains only the natural ingredients that are effective in supporting incredible hearing naturally.
**prodentim**
prodentim an advanced probiotic formulation designed to support exceptional oral hygiene while fortifying teeth and gums.
**vittaburn**
vittaburn is a liquid dietary supplement formulated to support healthy weight reduction by increasing metabolic rate, reducing hunger, and promoting fat loss.
**yusleep**
yusleep is a gentle, nano-enhanced nightly blend designed to help you drift off quickly, stay asleep longer, and wake feeling clear.
**synaptigen**
synaptigen is a next-generation brain support supplement that blends natural nootropics, adaptogens
**nitric boost**
nitric boost is a dietary formula crafted to enhance vitality and promote overall well-being.
**glucore**
glucore is a nutritional supplement that is given to patients daily to assist in maintaining healthy blood sugar and metabolic rates.
**wildgut**
wildgutis a precision-crafted nutritional blend designed to nurture your dog’s digestive tract.
**pineal xt**
pinealxt is a revolutionary supplement that promotes proper pineal gland function and energy levels to support healthy body function.
**energeia**
energeia is the first and only recipe that targets the root cause of stubborn belly fat and Deadly visceral fat.
**boostaro**
boostaro is a specially crafted dietary supplement for men who want to elevate their overall health and vitality.
**prostabliss**
prostabliss is a carefully developed dietary formula aimed at nurturing prostate vitality and improving urinary comfort.
**breathe**
breathe is a plant-powered tincture crafted to promote lung performance and enhance your breathing quality.
**potentstream**
potentstream is engineered to promote prostate well-being by counteracting the residue that can build up from hard-water minerals within the urinary tract.
**hepato burn**
hepato burn is a premium nutritional formula designed to enhance liver function, boost metabolism, and support natural fat breakdown.
**hepatoburn**
hepatoburn is a potent, plant-based formula created to promote optimal liver performance and naturally stimulate fat-burning mechanisms.
**cellufend**
cellufend is a natural supplement developed to support balanced blood sugar levels through a blend of botanical extracts and essential nutrients.
**prodentim**
prodentim is a forward-thinking oral wellness blend crafted to nurture and maintain a balanced mouth microbiome.
**flow force max**
flow force max delivers a forward-thinking, plant-focused way to support prostate health—while also helping maintain everyday energy, libido, and overall vitality.
**revitag**
revitag is a daily skin-support formula created to promote a healthy complexion and visibly diminish the appearance of skin tags.
**neurogenica**
neurogenica is a dietary supplement formulated to support nerve health and ease discomfort associated with neuropathy.
**sleep lean**
sleeplean is a US-trusted, naturally focused nighttime support formula that helps your body burn fat while you rest.
**memory lift**
memory lift is an innovative dietary formula designed to naturally nurture brain wellness and sharpen cognitive performance.